Premier Parfait Chunky vs. Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion: Which Plush Yarn Should You Choose?

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Nana's Attic! 💜

If you've ever stood in the yarn aisle wondering which plush yarn is the better choice, you're not alone. Two of my favorites are Premier Parfait Chunky and Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion from Hobby Lobby. While both are wonderfully soft, they create noticeably different finished projects.

Recently, I crocheted my Goose Creek Handbag in both yarns using the exact same pattern. The results made the differences easy to see.

Same Pattern, Different Results

Gray Handbag
Premier Parfait Chunky

White Handbag
Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion

Even though both bags were made from the same pattern, the white handbag is noticeably larger.

Premier Parfait Chunky

Premier Parfait Chunky is one of my favorite yarns for making stuffed animals.

Pros

• Extremely soft
• Excellent stitch definition
• Creates beautifully squishy plushies
• Works well for small and medium-sized amigurumi
• Great color selection

Best Uses

• Stuffed animals
• Plush toys
• Baby gifts
• Decorative amigurumi

Because the yarn is slightly finer, finished projects are generally a bit smaller while still remaining wonderfully soft.

Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion

Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion behaves more like a blanket yarn.

In fact, it reminds me quite a bit of Bernat Baby Blanket—soft, plush, and a little bulkier than Premier Parfait Chunky.

That extra thickness gives finished projects more structure.

Pros

• Slightly thicker yarn
• Creates larger finished projects
• Adds more body and stability
• Excellent for items that need to hold their shape

Best Uses

• Handbags
• Tote bags
• Blankets
• Pillows
• Larger plush projects

For my Goose Creek Handbag, Cozy Occasion produced a bag that felt sturdier and roomier without changing the pattern at all.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Which One Do I Recommend?

If I'm making a stuffed animal, I'll usually reach for Premier Parfait Chunky.

If I'm making something that needs to be sturdy—like a handbag—I prefer Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion.

Neither yarn is "better." They simply shine in different types of projects.

For my Goose Creek Handbag, I actually preferred the version made with Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion because it gave the finished bag more body and a larger finished size.

Final Thoughts

One of the fun things about crochet is discovering how much yarn choice affects the final project.

Using the same pattern with different yarns can completely change the size, feel, and purpose of what you create.

If you're making plush animals, Premier Parfait Chunky is hard to beat.

If you're making handbags, blankets, or other projects that benefit from extra structure, Yarn Bee Cozy Occasion is definitely worth trying.

👉 Grab the Goose Creek Handbag Pattern here!